Commerce Commission says mortgage advisers at risk of being ‘unduly influenced’ by commissions
Controversy has arisen based on the back of some comments John Small, Commerce Commission chair has made around the mortgage advice sector, on the back of the Commerce Commission releasing a draft report from the market study on the banking sector that has recently been released.
Small told journalists that he’s ‘not sure if you went to a mortgage broker that they would tell you’ about how they only work with certain banks and the different commissions advisers can receive, stating,
“From the broker's point of view, they will get different amounts of money from different banks. I'm not sure when you go to a mortgage broker that they would declare that to you.”
There has been a lot of feedback from mortgage advisers on the article posted on Good Returns, qualifying that they both state which banks they work with and the fees they receive from each bank in their disclosure statements all clients receive.
We study disclosure documents and note that they are all good at disclosing the range of lenders that the mortgage adviser offers to clients. The information is in the public disclosure document and is clear. The range that most mortgage advisers have access to through their aggregator is usually extensive as well - they are subject to commercial pressures and operate under strong incentives to ensure that they have relationships with at least the main lenders. Most have longer lists. Although we cannot access robust statistical information on disclosure on specific fees and commissions once a preferred lender is established, we note that there is clear guidance on how to make effective commission disclosure. So it would be interesting to hear more details on the experiences are leading the Commerce Commission to this viewpoint. On the other hand, the comments about AML/CFT limiting access to even basic banking services ring true to many of us in the sector.
More daily news:
Financial Advice NZ central branch meeting 26 March, Palmerston North