FMA acts against misleading customers

The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) has been busy, with the news this week full of stories of AA Insurance New Zealand Ltd (AAI) being ordered to pay a penalty and civil proceedings lodged against ASB Bank Limited (ASB).

AAI was ordered to pay a penalty of $6.175 million, for failing to apply multi-policy and membership discounts, as well as guaranteed no claims bonuses.

AAI was found to have misled customers about its multi policy discount offer in marketing material – marketing material said existing policy holders who added another policy would receive the discount immediately; however, AAI’s systems only applied the discount once the original policy came up for renewal. This issue affected 112,463 customers, who were overcharged approximately $4.89 million. In addition, AAI failed to apply discounts promised to NZAA members, affecting 90,129 customers who were overcharged approximately $2.95 million in total.

AAI were also found to have misrepresented that certain eligible customers would receive its guaranteed no claims bonus “for life”. Up until December 2011 AAI offered the bonus for each customer’s lifetime, as long as they remained insured with AAI. From 2012 the benefit only applied to the policy’s lifetime – yet AAI marketing continued to use the “for life” language without limitation. This affected 17,973 eligible customers, who were overcharged approximately $3.28 million.

Margot Gatland, FMA Head of Enforcement, said of the AAI judgement,

“AAI’s systems proved to be inadequate and its marketing was not kept in line with internal policies. This judgment sends a strong message to the industry that companies need to ensure their systems and processes are fit for purpose and customers’ interests put first.”

The FMA has filed civil proceedings against ASB for allegedly making false or misleading representations in regards to insurance products and banking services. Similar to AAI, ASB allegedly failed to apply multi policy discounts on ASB-branded insurance products, due to errors in the manual process at point of sale. Another issue arose when ASB staff misinformed customers with policies of insurance for caravans and trailers that they were eligible for the multi policy discount, despite those policies being ineligible. ASB also allegedly failed to consistently apply fee exemptions to certain customer accounts with access to ASB’s Fastnet Banking service, again due to failings in the manual processes. Between April 2014 and May 2022, a total of 23,062 customers were affected by the multi policy discount issue with the total value of overcharged premiums being approximately $2.8 million. During the same period, 2,435 customers were affected by the Fastnet Banking issue, totalling approximately $1,147,276 in overcharges. ASB has completed remediation work on both causes of action and has repaid affected customers, including use of money interest, and they self-reported the errors to the FMA.

Both of these cases demonstrate the willingness of the FMA to prosecute organisations who don’t fulfil their obligations to customers. They also highlight the importance of language in customer communications being crystal clear and that it is essential organisations have the systems-wide processes and checks in place to honour any discounts and offers made to customers. The FMA expect that if you make commitments to customers, you need to keep them, which we think is fair enough.

 

More news:

mySolutions webinar 'Building Stronger Client Connections : Enhancing Engagement and Loyalty' 16 October

Banking Ombudsman Scheme received 6,054 cases

From December, Sharesies’ KiwiSaver members can access the US markets by individual stocks or the Sharesies US500 fund

Previous
Previous

KiwiSaver financial hardship withdrawals continue to rise

Next
Next

Executive Team changes at Partners Life